Jump to content

Brentwood Academy vs Memphis East.. Who would win?


UCSportsFan
 Share

Recommended Posts

Memphis has long been the standard when it comes to high school basketball in the state of Tennessee and East seems to be the best team down there but are they truly the best TEAM in the state of Tennessee?  My money is on Brentwood Academy as the #1 team in the state of Tn regardless of classification.  East lost to Hamilton Heights earlier in the year.  HH just got beat by McCallie over the weekend and BA blasted McCallie by 35.  Seems to me its a no brainer here...Middle Tn has the best team in the state hands down.

Edited by UCSportsFan
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Memphis has long been the standard when it comes to high school basketball in the state of Tennessee and East seems to be the best team down there but are they truly the best TEAM in the state of Tennessee? My money is on Brentwood Academy as the #1 team in the state of Tn regardless of classification. East lost to Hamilton Heights earlier in the year. HH just got beat by McCallie over the weekend and BA blasted McCallie by 35. Seems to me its a no brainer here...Middle Tn has the best team in the state hands down.

Well, except Hamilton Heights beat Brentwood Academy, so that is sort of a circular hypothesis.

 

Could BA be the best team? Yes.

But are they the best hands down, I don't think so.

I think it is clear that the top 3 teams in the state are BA, Memphis East & Hamilton Heights.

Hamilton Heights beat both of the other two, so they have the strongest argument.

I think McCallie just played out of their minds vs HH to win & they conversely sucked an egg this week vs BA. The reality is that McCallie probably is 4th out of this group, but they knocked off the best team... I guess that is why they play the games...

All that being said, I'd pay good money to see East vs BA...

Edited by FootballFan51
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Well, except Hamilton Heights beat Brentwood Academy, so that is sort of a circular hypothesis.

 

Could BA be the best team? Yes.

But are they the best hands down, I don't think so.

I think it is clear that the top 3 teams in the state are BA, Memphis East & Hamilton Heights.

Hamilton Heights beat both of the other two, so they have the strongest argument.

I think McCallie just played out of their minds vs HH to win & they conversely sucked an egg this week vs BA. The reality is that McCallie probably is 4th out of this group, but they knocked off the best team... I guess that is why they play the games...

All that being said, I'd pay good money to see East vs BA...

Yeah so would I!  It would be a great game to watch for sure.   HH is definitely in the conversation, what a 4 team tourney that would be! 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

HH doesn't play by the same rules as BA or ME, so it's not a valid comparison. Look at what the national ranking services have done the last few years regarding teams like Oak Hill, Findlay Prep, Montverde, Huntington Prep, and La Lumiere. HH is in that category, overtly recruiting basketball players to the high school in a process that would not be legal in the TSSAA.

 

Also, HH losing to McCallie has a lot to do with the fact that they have already played 30 games this season and are probably worn out. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I dont get into who beat who to cancel out who's the better opponent. BA could beat East they've done it two summers in a row(yes summer ball i know) in Memphis. Hubie is a great coach but that team goes as far as Garland leads them and there isn't a pg in the STATE that can stop him. The two times i saw them play eachother, J.O. had big games both times and Garland had around 30 pts and set up teammates for open threes. BA played ball hawking D and didn't let TJ moss get going and Lomax(didn't play in the 2016 matchup) wasn't able to bully Garland like he does some. The top teams of DII-AA are extremely undervalued in my eyes. I also saw East barely beat a CBHS team that was basically 1 on 5 over the summer but thats another story. East also had two kids in the summer that are back at Hamilton now that are studs on the Highschool level that would've made a tremendous difference coming off the bench, and it could be argued if they had these two guys for depth they would be undefeated and champions of both of the big tournaments they lost. 

Edited by TonyG
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Finally, BA's schedule isn't even as remotely difficult as ME's is. ME is the best team in TN, and a Dec. 1 loss to HH doesn't change that. HH begins practicing from the first day of school, so by December 1, they are firing on all cylinders -- hence worn out now. 

 

Let's see where the final national rankings fall, and then we can talk.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

HH doesn't play by the same rules as BA or ME, so it's not a valid comparison. Look at what the national ranking services have done the last few years regarding teams like Oak Hill, Findlay Prep, Montverde, Huntington Prep, and La Lumiere. HH is in that category, overtly recruiting basketball players to the high school in a process that would not be legal in the TSSAA.

 

Also, HH losing to McCallie has a lot to do with the fact that they have already played 30 games this season and are probably worn out. 

McCallie has played 30 games also. We all know how basketball is. Anyone can be beat on any night when the talent level isn't a huge gap. I wouldn't pick Memphis East to lose against HH again, and I wouldnt pick HH to lose to McCallie if they played tomorrow. 

Edited by TonyG
  • Upvote 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I dont get into who beat who to cancel out who's the better opponent. BA could beat East they've done it two summers in a row(yes summer ball i know) in Memphis. Hubie is a great coach but that team goes as far as Garland leads them and there isn't a pg in the STATE that can stop him. The two times i saw them play J.O. had big games both times and Garland had around 30 pts and set up teammates for open threes. BA played ball hawking D and didn't let TJ moss get going and Lomax(didn't play in the 2016 matchup) wasn't able to bully Garland like he does some. The top teams of DII-AA are extremely undervalued in my eyes. I also saw East barely beat a CBHS team that was basically 1 on 5 over the summer but thats another story. East also had two kids in the summer that are back at Hamilton now that are studs on the Highschool level that would've made a tremendous difference coming off the bench, and it could be argued if they had these two guys for depth they would be undefeated and champions of both of the big tournaments they lost. 

Great evaluation!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Great evaluation!

 

I've honestly seen BA play too many times to doubt them. Every time i leave their game i tell myself "dang thats a great team with a great coach". BA is #24 now on unapproved website, next year we wont be having this conversation bc East doesn't lose any players that matter and BA loses an extremely talented Jeremiah Oatsvall along with some other quality shooters. I've been on board saying that if Garland wins another ring this year, i will not be surprised if he opts for a prep school bc he's already a top 10 player and has done it on a private school level. Maybe his Dad, a former NBA veteran, will think it's better for him to go and play a nationally ranked schedule and better himself before he steps on the college floor. They are originally from Indiana so a La Lumiere move won't shock me. This is just my wacky theory though lol. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Would be an amazing match up for sure. Hard to choose one side or the other but I guess I would have to go with BA strictly because not only do they have talent but they have been playing together for 4 years and watching them play and thier chemistry is out of the roof. Yes memphis east is staggeringly more athletic but BA's coach is tops in the state and I thin his schemes are great. With that said, this game would be one for the ages with a crazy enviroment.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

 Share

Announcements


  • Recent Posts

    • Ouch! If he's in the scrap business maybe 
    • That's a nice story but has little to nothing to do with what we're talking about. 
    • The winds of change are blowing in Hartsville.     Will be an interesting follow.    Would go back to the 90s and turn black the clock!
    • Did he promise you a coordinator job or something if he ever got a head coaching job? He resigned? He was at the top of the dugout last night calling plays. I wonder if those 30+ parents would let him give their kids a ride. by the way the board meeting was last night and it was not mentioned. must have been at the work session earlier this week which is not public. must be trying to keep it quiet.  Since you know so much, how much is Robbie Atwood willing to pay Adam Cothron?  Didn't you slander Eden earlier on here? You also didn't know he was a faculty coach again so how much do you really know? Some people outside this county baffle me with their need to slander others.    
    • He resigned smh, and have you ever heard of charged but not convicted. Some people in this county baffle me with their need to slander others. Have you asked any of the 30+ parents that signed a petition to get him reinstated at the board meeting this week how they feel about this? Just let it play out, at the end of the day the only people that will bring TC back are the ones that know what its about at its core.    People hate losing and they aren't used to it at TC. I for 1, and I'm sure others too, understand having a dip in talent and not being able to compete for a state title every year. But in the past, TC teams have outworked more talented teams, they didn't continuously lose the turnover battle, they didn't commit 8+ penalties in several games each season, and I believe several of the folks in town that want Blake out feel as if he is neglecting the history of the program. This is from a source that used to be extremely close to the program (not me lol), Blake gets out of school midday and the players show up and there is no practice plan or itinerary.  I also understand those that are on team Blake, when he has loads of talent, he wins. He does know football and he is a tremendous DC, and if the rumors are true then he will do great things. As for the board member issue, it is what it is, everyone that's true to the county know that and nothing has changed. I agree though that they should strive to make the facilities as good as we can. And as far as potential candidates, I agree there is very few options. West, Vetetoe (yes I know), and couple others that could have some interest. Whatever happens is massive for the program during a pivotal time before the next big wave of stars make their way through. 
×
  • Create New...