@WarEagleCartmanI believe people are tired of this thread, and I think it has ventured far from being a topic that should be in the 1A-2A subforum. Let’s just agree to disagree and give people a break. You’re not going to change my mind, and I’m not going to change yours.
Now, to answer your question…I certainly would. Lexington has a great football history especially under the tenure of Coach Jim Stowe (the father of Dyersburg coach Bart Stowe). The Tomcats and Tigers have similar stats, but I would give Haywood the advantage.
1. State Championships – Haywood 0, Lexington 0
(Haywood is 2-4 in 6 semifinal appearances. Lexington is 0-4 in 4 semifinal appearances.)
2. All Time Wins – Haywood 696 , Lexington 531. Haywood and Lexington have met 21 times throughout history. Haywood leads the series 12-7-2.
Haywood has had 75 winning seasons, Lexington has had 57
3. Recent Success
Wins over the last 5 decades including 2020 and 2021 - Haywood 385, Lexington 371
Wins over the last 5 years - Haywood 56 (with 3 district titles-2019,2020,2021), Lexington 32 (with 1 district title-2020)
Haywood has won 16 playoff games over the past 5 years.. Lexington’s has won 5 playoff games over the past 5 years
Haywood has played in four straight semifinals (2018, 2019, 2020, 2021), Lexington has played in one semifinal during that time (2020).
Haywood defeated Lexington 17-14 in the 2020 state semifinals.
4. Consistency
Haywood has won 10 or more games every year over the past 6 years, Lexington has won 10 or more games only once (2020) in the last 6 years.
Community Support – Advantage Lexington.