I never once mentioned scholarships, I said specifically financial aid.
After my sons Freshman year, we had over 10 high level wrestlers apply at McCallie the next 3 years that would have qualified for a very high percentage if not 100% of financial aid based off their families income level but McCallie didnt grant them any aid at all because that money was tied up in football. Just because you qualify doesn’t mean you are getting it or the entire amount you qualify for. It completely up to the schools if they want to give out aid and how much they give out based of the financial aid calculator.
And, yes you are correct, the financial aid system does penalize middle class families as once the family income gets above 150k then you only qualify for a tiny bit of aid and for those families the tuition at McCallie, Baylor, and MBA is just to much to swing.
As for the cross country team, the McCallie wrestling team was really good in 18 and 19. My sons freshman year in 18, McCallie would have won beaten Christian Brothers in both traditional and dual state if River Henry had not gotten hurt. His sophomore year, they lost to Baylor on the last match to lose dual state. I would aLao argue that you are more likely get full pay kids in cross country than you are in wrestling.
My point on all of this is that the amount of financial a sports program gets at McCallie, Baylor, MBA is single determining factor of success of those sports teams.
As for as judging the overall ability of a coaching staff, for me and my son we looked at different coaching staffs and our determining factor was which staff would prepare him best for D1 which is why we eventually decided on McCallie. Yost has produced the most D1 wrestlers of any active coach in TN and Pitts has developed probably the 2nd most.
This past season 3 programs had 4 wrestlers that wrestled D1, Christian Brothers, Baylor and McCallie. As far as starting varisty matches this past season Baylor had 1 of their 4 that did, Christian Brothers had 2 and McCallie had 3. So I will say it again, McCallie has the best coaching staff in the state.