You guys do remember that nobody gets a medal at the end of the year for what they were ranked? Also remember that high school kids read these boards just as much, if not more than, us adults.
I do not know who makes the rankings, but I do know whoever it is he has been doing it for years and seems to be very knowledgeable on the sport. If you personally think you can do better, please do! Invest your time and energy into looking up results for 3 divisions- each with 14 different weight classes-, make your list and post a link for everyone else to critique. I am not trying to defend who makes the rankings, as I do not even know who that is, just trying to keep some perspective. It is perfectly fine if you want to make an argument about a head-to-head win or loss or even a common opponent that you think is being over looked. However, please remember my first two points above before you insult 16 year old kids online.