Private schools recruit kids for athletic purposes and provide financial aid to some.
Public schools recruit kids for athletic purposes and give special transfers to some.
What's the difference?
Both D1 and D2 schools have some integrity issues among their ranks.
Pearl-Cohn would have never made the playoffs if they played only with kids in their zone. Hillsboro wouldn't be able to put 11 on the field if they were restricted to kids living in their zone.
BA, MBA, and others have agents of their school, as well as their actual staff memers, who begin recruiting kids in the early grades, and offering incentives to parents and kids alike to attend their schools.
I say we need a rigid set of rules, established by leaders from schools of every type (urban, rural, public, private), that reflect the best interests of the honest member schools across the state, and are enforced justly and honestly. No division is needed. Integrity is needed.