I know I'm bout to ###### off half the lacrosse community, but I saw Jimbo play against MBA today, and I must say, I was not impressed at all. He is good...he reads passes really well, clears really well, is very confident, and very aware. The only problem is, he couldn't stop anything. Half the time, he wouldn't even move when the ball was shot. Chris Taylor is probably not as good at interceptions or awareness...but he can stop the ball, and thats what counts. I'd say out of seeing the top three goalies play Jimbo is last in ability to stop the ball. Fortunately for MUS, their defense is so good Jimbo is able to get by without being the best at stoping the ball.
I don't even like CBHS, as a matter of fact I hate them, but Chris T. easily deserves 1st team over Rainer. If Taylor's defense was anything like Jimbo's, CBHS would be unbeatable.
I don't like hating on other players, but I have heard so much about Rainer, and then to see him, I was very disappointed. Gibson is a total badass, though...respect all the way.