Riverdaleman,
You bring up some good points. I'm guessing the intention of the new rules is to keep the kids from feeling forced to play a sport year round. I think the TSSAA is missing the point that the kids who are dedicated to a sport want to devote as much free time to improving their skills as possible. You said your kid may or may not be very talented, but I know that the first thing that separates the kids who make it from the ones who don't is drive and dedication, and that eventually trumps natural ability, as I'm sure you know.
But for where I'm from in Clarksville, the whole year round concept is still relatively new, and I see them trying to get control of it before it gets out of hand. I graduated only 5 years ago, but we never had summer high school ball, tryouts during summer. We didn't have middle school ball then and travel teams were still pretty hard to come by. The amount of baseball these kids are getting to play now is incredible, and I only wish I would have had that opportunity. You all are right, how can we ever compete on a state level with states where the weather permits you to play year round. Now when we're running traveling teams we are having to squeeze 75 games into 75 days just for them to get the PT.
Like I said before, I'm not a fan of the summer high school teams just because of the limit exposure the kids get, but if we're hiring guys as "coaches", it seems silly to put restrictions on which months they can do their job. Seems silly.
I also don't care for the double standard that allows football to be an exception to this rule. I don't understand that one bit.