Jump to content

goryan

Members
  • Posts

    11
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by goryan

  1. Dont care who the better school is or which school has the better kids. In the end, we are all Catholic.

     

    Who is gonna win, FRHS or JP2?

     

    FRHS thrashed a not good Hillwood team and JP2 somehow lost to Greenbrier.

     

    Thoughts?

     

    The fact that JPII lost to Greenbriar having not seen JPII this year, tells me they may be one dimensional, even more so than last year when Father Ryan beat JPII/Golden Tate to everyone's surprise. That is with the exception of Father Ryan. Having watched Father Ryan friday night, they have a number of ways to beat a good defensive team, let alone a bad one. And their defense was much better than expected. While it is unlikely that you stop little Tate, he will not outscore the Father Ryan offense. Last year's game was an exceptional game that few will ever forget. Win or lose. My bet is this will be a forgetable game for JPII. Father Ryan by 2 TD's and maybe more.

  2. Perhaps the answer to your question is that Father Ryan see's its students in more than an athletic sense, but instead see's the needs of all its students athletes or not. I believe that this is the correct way to give financial aid. The more students you help, the better. And athletics should not have anything to do with it. I believe that Father Ryan comes as close to reaching this goal as any private school in the state of Tennessee. Rumor was that JPII was given leeway to do a little extra in the beginning by the Bishop at that time. Rumor further has it that some of the more famous players who attended there were financed by wealthly benefactors to the school, who knows for sure. But I think that success in athletics is secondary to success in school and life for its students and it is not worth losing financial aid just for the sake of playing in a different division and maybe being more successful in sports. Lastly, this would be devastating to the most needy families who otherwise without financial assistence simply could not have their children attend the school.

     

    I agree with your post 100% and I would add that in cases where you have an exceptional athlete like a Golden Tate who wanted to attend Father Ryan, that their be opportunity to bring exception to the otherwise "rule". I have seen both BA and MBA hand pick exceptional athletes out of the parochial league before they even leave the middle school. Again, these athletes would have been the difference in a mediocre record, and a run for a championship. The coaches in these school's should create awareness so that potentially some kind of an aid package can be considered that otherwise might not have been offered. For example a 7th grader at St. Henry's goes to BA for 8th grade where a financial package made the difference. Yes, I too had heard of a benefactor at JPII, but do not clearly understand how this works for any school. Does anyone care to comment on this? I would assume there are benefactors at BA and MBA who make the difference in a kid coming there versus elsewhere. I will add, that if anyone remembers Cincinnati Moeller and Jerry Faust, I can tell you kids moved from all over the country to live with relatives, friends, etc. to play for what was then the top high school program in the country back in the 70's and 80's. It was a parochial school, and again I understand had many benefactors. Where does each school's "need based" scholarship fund come from? Does anyone know the ins and outs of this?

  3. When the financial aid blast comes out this early, it is usually not a good sign.

     

     

    Father Ryan as I stated on my post should win at least 7 games this year. They have a mature offensive line with an athletic QB in Guidrey and a RB that nearly ran for 1000 yards last year with a tough schedule. The defense is where we will have to see. Kevin Nix is an outstanding LB that returns. I do know that. Should be a very good year for Father Ryan, but it is a watered down schedule as in years past due to the merge of DII AA and AAA. Again, my point was simply that if Father Ryan was as aggressive as most other DII schools in respect to financial aid to athletes we would get the 2 or 3 kids each year that are often times the difference in 3-7 and 8-2. There is no doubt Father Ryan otherwise gets good athletes from the catholic football league. It should also be noted that indeed Pope John Paul II hit Ryan hard. Imagine the past three years if you had a merged Father Ryan/JPII team. Can anyone say state champions........

  4. It was highlighted in the Tennessean several years ago. Father Ryan provides financial aid based on need like any other private school, then they cut that aid roughly in half so that they can provide aid to more students. It has been this way for a very long time. So, Golden Tate comes along. I talked with one of his family members when he was an 8th grader, and he was on his way to Father Ryan. Can you guess what happen. JPII provided the Tate family full aid. Father Ryan did not. What would you do....... A huge problem I would say if you need to get those 2 or 3 athletes that were already in your system but went elsewhere.

     

    Last year lost to Baylor by 4 at Baylor. Lost to MBA by 7. If you saw this game, some would say the refs blew a call or two. Lost to McCallie by 6 and down to BA at half 10-7. Father Ryan showed up last year in every game with the possible exception of the Franklin game. Father Ryan entered this game 2-0 and may have been a little over confident. At the same time this was the same team Father Ryan destroyed the year before for their first win. Franklin was ready. It may also be interesting to note that Father Ryan beat Ravenwood in a week zero Friday night under the lights game. This game was played for keeps. Of course Ravenwood was in the 5A championship game last year.

     

    When it is all said and done, Ryan will show up offensively this year. Ryan Berry will be tough to stop with a big mature offensive line coming back. They should be able to score some points. The question mark for me is the D. With a favorable schedule this team should win 7 games showing up. Good Luck Father Ryan. Father Ryan wins the first one by 14.

  5. If my understanding is correct, CBHS Freshman running back is out (academics) and their go to reciever is out due to injury. Can anyone confirm this? This being the case, already having won this game earlier in the year 37-14 I trust Father Ryan will be making the trip to McCallie the following week. After Friday's performance, they have to believe a trip to Murfreesboro is not out of the question.

  6. Yes, at a first glance this would appear to be a 3 TD advantage for BA. Prior to the 2 transfers arrival (I know one is out) based on the 2007 class clashes with BA along the way (Freshman and JV), this would be a fairly even game. I am not predicting an upset, but if BA thinks they are going to show up and win, and FR gets some breaks, this could turn out to be a competitive game to the end. FR will have to bring a balanced offense (both pass and run equally) and not allow the big play from BA on offense. Yes, no one thought possible that FR would beat CBHS and Franklin in consecutive years. The same will be true of these next two games. FR may just be due :thumb: .

  7. I don't think that FR has anyone with the type of break away speed that Tate has. MBA moved the ball well against JPII and held Coffey pretty much in check. I agree that it's going to be a slugfest but I also think that MBA is faster and better upfront. I'm still taking MBA.

     

    How many MBA athletes healthy or not run a legitimate 4.39 40? Father Ryan has one. Chris Hohl WR/DB. Go to www.40speed.com where this is noted on the site. I believe Golden is noted as having run a 4.42 40.

     

    You obviously have not seen this team move to the ball. They have tremendous speed all around. Ryan will win this game. Not sure by how many, but they will find a way to win this one.

  8. Congrats to Franklin. I predicted a 2 TD win for the Irish. No surprises this year as Franklin was ready and Father Ryan never showed up. Games are not won when you turn the ball over and play without emotion. The future will show that you did beat a solid Father Ryan team. They will rebound from this, better from the experience.

  9. When you have as many turn overs as Father Ryan had Friday night you can expect to lose. All things considered a 2-1 start is where they hoped to be. If revenge is a motive not that it should be needed, Father Ryan will win this game. In respect to QB, Justin Guidry given a week of practice with the first team and some confidence will surprise many. He is quick and has a strong arm. Provided the line shows up for this game on Friday, we may even see a long ball to spread the field that we have not seen thus far. This team will continue to improve and hope that this Franklin game was a wake up call. You just can't show up and win. There was no emotion on the Father Ryan side line last night.....

  10. They key for Father Ryan in this game will be shutting down Tod Cambell, If they are not carefully he will make big play after big play, those CBs and Safteys are going to have to be on their toes all night.

    Check out www.40speed.com an advertiser on this site. Go half way down on the right side to see Father Ryan WR/CB Hohl featured on this site. If he and Bateman All-State Linebacker are on the field together, Campbell will be a non factor in this game. Ryan by 14 B)

×
  • Create New...