If someone only reads this board, its pretty obvious that it depends on who's ox is getting gored. You can pick out the CBHS supporters, the McCallie detractors, fans from Chattanooga who only know their own officials. Folks, we always like our own better or better the devils we know?
I saw one fan screaming at the top of her lungs how strong the air intake was of a particular official calling on the mat. She was very clear, three times she was clear. But listen, I know DGilbert, he is a friend of mine. On one thread on this board, he was lauded as the best in Clarksville and maybe all of Chattanooga. Evidently this lady and the other post I read dont seem to agree. Amazing huh?
That said, the same guys cannot always call every state meet. And for the individuals at least, the coaches do have some say as to who gets to the state tournament to call. They have a strong voice the selection of the officials for their respective regions and that leads to the pool TSSAA selects from for the state tourney.
You have to continually feed the pool of officials, so as the older ones call it quits, there is some new blood coming in. It takes the new ones a few years to allow old prejudices to wear off. Our coaches arent easy on newbies either, sort of a baptism by fire. Those that make it through are usually well battle tested long before they call any state contests.
Its good to have some representation from across the state in officiating, maybe. If an official is not used to the heat and intensity of a McCallie/Baylor match or MBA/Ryan match, its unfair to both official and wrestler. If a region has no representative team in the state duals, should that officials association be represented? Could this be proportional?
Had the MBA/CBHS 171 bout gone the other way, who would be screaming? And would the MBA coach be missing the state tourney? The end of the bout, you had either 1 pt escape and a possible 1 pt fleeing the mat. Would that had been better than a two point reversal? Under normal circumstances, the mat official is getting an opinion from the assistant, but ultimately he makes the call.
I haved watched this board for some time, and decided to speak up. I think you may rather I hit the snooze button again.
Everyone needs some stroke every now and then.
Stroker