A few notes, if I may...
First, it would be nice to have official stats to use when writing. Typically local papers are not dailies and an e-mail the following day with stats FOR BOTH TEAMS would be nice. For dailies that actually staff the games, it would be great to have the information immediately after the game.
Secondly, stats should be more than just scoring, I agree, but it's hard to keep up with everything alone. I'd love to ballyhoo the "double doubles", "10 assists", etc, but I quit trying to keep anything except shots and points about the fourth time I got a call from Little Johnny's Dad-Mom-Girlfriend (take your pick) telling me I'd missed a rebound or assist. It's just not worth the trouble of identifying my notes as "unofficial" only to raked over the coals.
Thirdly, the average attendance at a high school football game (at least in Middle Tennessee) is upwards of 1,500, with big games (and I'll single out Rutherford County here, though it's not my territory) pushing 5,000-7,500 through the turnstiles. Average basketball attendance is closer to 400, with a HUGE crowd being 1,200-1,500 numbers.
Finally, writers in the under 35 category, especially the newbies, are infected with what I call the ESPN/USA Today virus. It's not about reporting what happened, it's about being cute/inflammatory/opinionated/humorous (the ESPN effect) in one two-sentence, 20 word paragraph. It's not about telling the reader what happened at a contest as an observer anymore, it's about how short you can make your editorial (USA TODAY effect).
The craft of journalism is a dying art.
Sorry I built that soap box so tall.