Last year they both were deserving but Winn was the deserved winner, IMO. I understand what you mean with Rice, he's a gamer and a great football player. He has to do a lot for his team. Winn is the better overall athlete/QB, hard to argue against that. His completion % is pretty impresseive for anyone. Just based on this year, I think Rice will win just because how this year has played out for both players. Who knows what kind of stats thy could have if they got to play full games every week. Shoot, one of the RBs might slip in as a finalist. They've both have had great careers and hopefully one will get to settle it on the field.