When I coached basketball, I never gave trophies to the "superstars". None of my trophies were scoring based.
Most Charges, Best Defense, Best FT %, Most Rebounds, Most Steals, Most Improved and for example the Lady Ranger Award, that goes to the a person, who is a leader, hustler, team player, etc... None like Best Offense, Best 3-point shooter, etc..
ALL trophies should be earned at all levels!