First of all, your first sentence is a lie. Secondly, if you, Catholic, played D-I instead of D-II, you wouldn't be in Class A anyway you fool, Catholic would be in Class AA, because you have 400+ students. Class A is for schools with less than 400 students. CAK only has 249.
By the way, Catholic doesn't choose to play D-II, they have to. HAPPY RECRUITING, you'll need it to be the best football team, of the whole 9 teams state-wide, that play in your football division.