Here's the situation: Runners at first and third with one out, and I'm coaching third. A fly ball is hit to right field, and the runner from third leaves a couple of steps before the catch. The right fielder throws home and the runner from third is safe while the runner on first advances to second. The field ump and the opposing coach both saw the runner from third leave early. The opposing coach comes out of the dugout and tells his pitcher to appeal to the field ump and throw to third. The pitcher does so, and proceeds to throw the ball over the third baseman's head and into the home team's open dugout. It was then ruled a dead ball, and the ump awarded third base to the runner on second. Assuming the appeal was now negated, the pitcher returned to the mound and pitched to the next batter. After the inning, the field ump told me that even after the dead ball, the pitcher could have thrown to third and the runner who left early would have been ruled out, and the runner who was awarded third could have stayed there. I have searched the rules on dead ball and I can't find anything to support the ump's logic. Between innings, I asked the homeplate if he agreed with the field ump--he did not. Who is right? As it turned out, it didn't become an issue but it could have. It seems to me that a dead ball should negate all prior play. Any thoughts?