It seems to me that the main issue is that the students be allowed to play in a “fair” playing field. The problem with this is that someone has to “define” fair. Is fair where every school, player, coach and team must abide by the same rules? Is fair where the teams, players, or coaches that excel year in and year out must play under a “handicap” so others will have a chance to keep the score close, if not win? Or is fair where there is a rule that every player on every team must have playing time in every game? All these are what I have heard parents say is “fair.” Or is it something else? I think that fair is one set of rules for all. Rules administered, enforced, followed, and penalized equally if broken. That is not what we have, but it’s not the public schools that are handicapped. It’s the private schools. The public high school coach is allowed to attend middle schools to speak with all the eighth grade students about playing for them, IF that high school is considered the natural progression for all students of that school. The unfair part is that TSSAA doesn’t consider private high schools to have a natural progression or feeder school that is public. So two schools (private and public) in the same area don’t have the same rules. Public can contact the students in middle school and give “recruitment” speeches, but privates cannot, unless it is their own middle school.
Let me add that my kids go to public, and to my knowledge, no one in my family has ever been enrolled or employed in a private school. It just seems “fair” to me that the rules apply equally across the board.