I think you're right that they may have the deepest pitching roster, but when it comes down to it, I don't think they are very consistent once you pass Smith. Overbey isn't even all that consistent. If JCS can get a BIG offensive burst in any of the games, they will have the upper hand. Defense wins championships but 358 runs so far this season sure doesn't hurt! USJ is no doubt the best team in the tournament, but I don't see them with as much longevity as JCS. The Eagles can put together games by pitching by committee to stay competitive while the "Air Raid Offense" gets the job done. The team that capitalizes most often will come out on top. That has been JCS's problem all year, they leave too many opportunities on the field against USJ. I just can't see USJ beating JCS 7 times in a year.
Anything is possible between the two teams, but the DII-A champion will be from the West. The only question is, which side of Oil Well/Pipkin road will it be from?