Ok, I have played against him this year and im just going to say yes he is that good. One of our best hitters hit a absolute rocket in the hole and it seemed like he took 2 steps in the hole and back handed it and threw him out by 5 steps and the guy running runs a 6.9 60. I don't care what anyone says he is all around a great player he has speed, he can hit, and his glove is tremendous. The game you saw may not have been his best game, but you have to look at this he is HUMAN and human's make mistakes. Either way you look at it he is one of the best around the East.