Parker is much more impressive, the quality of opponents that he faced isn't even a comparison. Honestly, just as i read earlier in the boards, Giles QB should be in the race. Didn't James have around the same rushing totals last season? I know his TD weren't as many, but he wasn't even an all region selection last season with around the same totals. I don't believe it matters what anyone says on a CoachT message board at this point, but Giles QB should have been a semi finalist and Parker is most impressive based on quality of opponents.