Schools that aren't dominant really don't really care how a sports program becomes dominant, they only care about how that dominance can be ended. CPA has always been about attracting, not recruiting, players. They are one of the few non apologetic Christian world view curriculums and they strive for absolute excellence in everything they do (not saying they are the only ones that do that). That combination, with excellent coaches that focus more on the kid than the wins, attracts parents of athletes to the school. Plus winning breeds winning. Another interesting thing is almost every good private school CPA plays has over 20% African American players that have recruited from the public schools. Nothing wrong with that and I think it is great these kids have the opportunity to go to great schools. However, as evidence of CPA not focusing on recruiting, but attracting, they have this year, I think, 3 African American kids (and 1 starter), out of a roster of 80+. That is not because they don't want them. It is because they don't build a roster by recruiting from the area public schools.
In contrast, I was at the Boyd Buchanan game and at least 1/3 of their roster of about 50 were African Americans. I do not know the stats but I wonder what percent of the overall student body at Boyd Buchanan is African Americans? Again, this is facts, not a racist comment. The point is that when you see a large number of African American football players at a predominately white private school you know the program is being built by recruiting. You see it at Ensworth, BA and others.
And I repeat, it is great for those kids and there is nothing wrong with it.
Most (not all) of CPA's players are from "CPA families" that have had kids go to the school since elementary and middle school. The culture, atmosphere and tradition attract the families of these athletes and there has been a stream of success.
Bottom line, the TSSAA has proved for many years that they (and the schools that lose and complain) do not like dominance by any team and will change the rules to break that dominance. This latest change moved CPA to D2AAA.