I would have to disagree with your assumption of MBA having a better team in 2004. One loss I might agree but to lose twice in the same year doesn't equate to a better team in my opinion
Both games were close...within a touchdown, and really the teams were evenly matched. Both games were played in Memphis and if that had been reversed the results might have been as well. The second game in particular was tough. The conditions were horrible. It had rained early in the week and then gotten cold, all the mud had frozen. It was a cold night. The final was MUS 10 MBA 7. The MUS TD came on a gadget play, and other then that their offense didn't do much. I don't remember exactly what happened, MBA either blocked a punt or recovered a fumble, but they got the ball at the MUS 10 with about 2 minutes to go. They picked up 6 on first down, and 3 on 2nd down. So it was 3rd and goal from the one and Rutledge makes a call I have never understood. Rather then loading up the backfield and running behind our all-american left tackle, he puts the ball in the hands of our sophomore QB and runs an option. The QB goes the wrong way and is stopped for a short loss. The kicker slips on the field goal try and it is blocked...game over. That game broke my sons heart. He played dline and they all played their butts off. Woulda, coulda, shoulda. That 2004 MBA team overcame so much adversity with injuries starting with the first day of two a days. MUS went on to wear BA out in the championship game.
If you go back and look at the fg I think you will see that MBA didn't move a tackle over or move the ball to compensate for the ball being on the right hash and that made a short corner for our best block guy and he got it. The best of memory it was a fumbled punt that set up the final drive but I might be wrong. I would agree that they were evenly matched and if played in Nashville it might have been different.