I haven't seen Carver. However, I have watched the film from MUS's 1st game vs. CBHS and clearly saw that Taylor did not make 17 saves that game, in fact I think the number was 8. Don't get me wrong, Taylor is a good goalie, but padding the stats doesn't mean anything at the end of the season when the educated coaches cast their votes.
My pick is MY goalie, of course, Jimbo Rainer.