I don't ask this in an aggressive tone - it's a legitimate question and observation. How many Catholic people are there in TN? And how many families in TN want a Catholic education for their child? Historically, catholic schools thrived in inner cities because they provided families (regardless of religious denomination) with structure and lower price tags. Their price tags have gone up to a point that the difference between tuitions isn't the same. In fact, it looks lie DA is about $2k less than Pope Prep this year if I am looking at websites correctly.
It will require some serious internal reflection and community involvement. 12 football players each year receiving 100% of the aid they qualify for is a huge investment. Does Pope Prep or any school think the return will be worth it? Go to their website. There is a video from September about the master plan. The first three items discussed are the chapel, academic spaces, and student gathering spaces. All very worthwhile causes and an ambitious and strong plan. So they're making it pretty clear in my mind that the money they need and want to spend in the coming years isn't focused on athletics or FA at a level it would need to be to be successful annually in TN D2 football.
My fear - for many D2 schools - is that the costs of running successful athletic programs each year will become really burdensome. Investments will be made - but can they be sustained? FRA makes a good hire but couldn't get past the CPA hurdle and now as CPA leaves AA, BGA has made a move and is now more competitive. At the same time, DA, Goodpasture, and Pope Prep are slipping a bit. Another thread is discussing the challenges at MBA, but in AAA CPA is moving up, Lipscomb got itself in trouble but more importantly, the $ Dilfer was able to put into the program himself has been gone for 2 years now. BA made a good hire but is losing some good pieces that never reached the expectations people had. Ensworth appears to be heading up. And no one can compete with the financial resources of McCallie and Baylor. Yes, as boarding schools they can bring in talent from anywhere but more importantly, they have the money to afford people and spaces.
Sustained success is expensive.