You may be able to compare the talent of the QB's involved, but you must take into consideration the supporting cast for each QB. Imagine having a stable of running backs, several athletic targets to throw to, dominate O line, and a lock down defense = Alcoa. Simply, the QB doesn't have to win the thing by himself. Harb is good, but their overall team can not be compared to Alcoa. I think RW will struggle a little bit against the pass, but they will fight hard and be prepared by the coaching staff. Too early to predict a winner. What is your take on the situation WaggleRT?