N.L. Cy Young

[goldenboy]

I don't think that a closer should get it but I'm gonna vote for Gagne because I don't think any of these starters deserve it as much as him. He rocks. :justwrestle:

[goldenboy]

.......And with one vote Mr. Eric Gagne wins!!! lol

[WesVLT]

I think Ortiz is the man to win it this year.

[Gail]

Nope Goldenboy, I think Ortiz is winning! I really like John Smoltz..but he hasn't got to pitch very much lately.

[goldenboy]

I'm glad somebody else finally voted, I was starting to think with one vote Gagne would win. lol If the person you think should win it isn't on here please let me know, what do you think Opperman?

[jcmjeff2006]

Im going with Prior....this guy has been nearly unhittable down the stretch....

[Opperman]

I'm glad somebody else finally voted, I was starting to think with one vote Gagne would win. lol If the person you think should win it isn't on here please let me know, what do you think Opperman?

It's a close race...Gagne probably has the best case of any closer ever for the Cy, but most of the time, a good starter for 200 innings is more valuable than even a great closer for 70 innings. This year, Gagne's just been playing a different game, much like Bonds as a hitter.

 

I really don't know off-hand whom I'd vote for.

[goldenboy]

Since I don't think they'll give it to Gagne I'm hoping Prior will win it. He's been pretty much untouchable since he got off the DL. I don't really want to start an A.L. Cy Young poll but who do ya'll think should win it? I think it has to be either Roy Halladay or Esteban Loaiza.