NC80, your response is very logical. As a former club president, I am very excited that the TSSAA is finally at least considering the option to allow players the opportunity to play club ball during high school season without losing eligibility. During my tenure, I couldn't even get a cognitive response when I questioned the rule, much less any discussion on a change.
Most of the better high school coaches around Chattanooga also coach club. The idea that a coach wouldn't do what is in the best interest of a player is patently absurd. Bottom line, though, it should be the players and parents' decision what to do, not an agency.