I have played both courses numerous times and I love them both. I think Old Fort is the better venue for several reasons:
1. It is probably cheaper than Tims Ford
2. Tim's Ford does not have the amenities near by that Old Fort has (ex. hotels, restaurants)
3. Old Fort has a better set up for high school caliber golfers. There are a lot of high school golfers that can play anywhere, but there are quite a few players that would struggle mightily at Tim's Ford, mainly due to the high fescue rough, tree lined fairways, and more places to get in trouble. I feel Old Fort can be set up hard enough to challenge the better golfers while at the same time being fair to the rest of the field.