First off, I am not on either side. I played for a public school and we where in the same district as a private school and we looked at it as a great way to get noticed by everyone. My brother also played for a big time private school so I am neutral. No one knows if they recruit or not so my eyes, I think they should put all public schools in D1 and private schools in D2. The way it is now, you can't be a public school in D2 so why should private schools be able to play in D1. They should let all private schools recruit in D2. People will do it one way or another so just put them together so no one has a unfair advantage. On the last note I am aware that public schools do recruit also. State you beat ideas!