Close games go to the team who didn't turn it over and rebounded, most of the time.
York turned it over 12 times to Gibson's 8, but out rebounded them 32-26. Speaks to the closeness because it evens it all out. With the foul count even, the discrepancy in FTs seems to be that York's were in 1-1 situations or while shooting as to Gibson's were not in the act.