I believe you have a valid point.
I was kind of surprised myself that Antonio beat out Skogen in 1A.
The last stats I saw was that Skogen of Temple had like 2,000 yards receiving with like 22 TD's and Robinson (SP) had something like 1,000 yards and 15 TD's.
I really don't understand how they pick in these things. From my understanding half the ones who vote have never even seen many of the players they pick. So you're right it is kind of bogus.
I really thought Smithson from Temple would have been picked as well over Antonio.