I think a better solution would be just to co-op for football, where safety is more overarching concern that giving all the kids an opportunity to play. For other sports like basketball/volleyball/baseball/softball, consolidation would eliminate several opportunities for kids to play. While the overall team might be better, isn't the point high school athletics to give kids a chance to compete and learn valuable life lessons. Having one team instead of four make them more competitive, it takes away more opportunities. As far as academics are concerned, having a smaller student-teacher ratio is essential to meeting the needs of every kid, which could be accomplished in either situation.