Knox Catholic v. Goodpasture

[Hoya]

So tell me what you're gonna do with Maryville - a public school that allows students (athletes) to transfer into their school from out of their school district? They've won the 2A football championship for like 5 years in a row. Isn't this the same thing you accuse the privates of doing? So publics do the exact same thing.

 

Exactly, oknative, except you may be confusing Maryville (AAAA) with Alcoa (AA). Same rules. Same results. Both public. Both in the same county and both fantastically good.

[oknative]

Exactly, oknative, except you may be confusing Maryville (AAAA) with Alcoa (AA). Same rules. Same results. Both public. Both in the same county and both fantastically good.

 

Oops. Guess that was one of those Freudian slips. Either one fits interchangeably. So CJFM, what about both of those publics? Same question.

 

But I already know your answer because you public/private split proponents don't want to address the real issue of students attending other schools from outside their own districts - which publics and magnets also do - you just want to penalize only the privates. Shouldn't every public and magnet who do this have the multiplier imposed and be forced into another division with the privates?

[BigG]

Well, it's not like I couldn't see this coming down the path...

 

Sorry guys, but we need to move this to another thread. I'll leave a link so you can continue the discussion ad nauseum.

[Hoya]

No apology necessary, G. It gets so old. /dry.gif" style="vertical-align:middle" emoid="

[easttnref]

well why can we not make the privates in Div II bigs with bigs a little ones with little ones

still able to play under TSSAA just not competing for state tournaments with publics

but able to compete in regular season competition

[BigG]

well why can we not make the privates in Div II bigs with bigs a little ones with little ones

still able to play under TSSAA just not competing for state tournaments with publics

but able to compete in regular season competition

 

Something similar to this was rumored to be a possibility.

[easttnref]

Something similar to this was rumored to be a possibility.

 

 

 

and so would you be opposed to something like this G

[supersteve17]

and so would you be opposed to something like this G

 

 

The fact of the matter is that it doesn't matter what the good coach thinks (no offense coach). Independent schools in Tennessee are such a small minority that they have NO representation on the TSSAA Board of Control or the Legislative Council. They (independent schools) will do what they are told to do by the powers that be (or else they will drop out of TSSSAA -- which is not very likely).