Jump to content


Why login?

  • It's free
  • Participate in the discussions
  • Contribute schedules, rosters and scores
  • Hide the advertising on the message boards by becoming a Plus member
  • Welcome to CoachT.com!

    You can't become a part of our great high school sports community without logging in!

    Regular visitors will tell you: they love keeping up with teams outside their own area. That only happens when we share information here on CoachT.com!

    Don't have an account? It only takes a second to create one, and it's even easier with a Facebook or Twitter account!
    Photo

    Brentwood Academy vs Memphis East.. Who would win?


    • Please log in to reply
    12 replies to this topic

    #1 UCSportsFan

    UCSportsFan

      Most Valuable Player

    • CoachT+
    • 5,643 posts

    Posted 2 weeks ago

    Memphis has long been the standard when it comes to high school basketball in the state of Tennessee and East seems to be the best team down there but are they truly the best TEAM in the state of Tennessee?  My money is on Brentwood Academy as the #1 team in the state of Tn regardless of classification.  East lost to Hamilton Heights earlier in the year.  HH just got beat by McCallie over the weekend and BA blasted McCallie by 35.  Seems to me its a no brainer here...Middle Tn has the best team in the state hands down.


    Edited by UCSportsFan, 2 weeks ago.

    • 0
    Everyone looks good in "WARM-UPS"

    #2 FootballFan51

    FootballFan51

      Medalist

    • Members
    • 1,063 posts

    Posted 2 weeks ago

    Memphis has long been the standard when it comes to high school basketball in the state of Tennessee and East seems to be the best team down there but are they truly the best TEAM in the state of Tennessee? My money is on Brentwood Academy as the #1 team in the state of Tn regardless of classification. East lost to Hamilton Heights earlier in the year. HH just got beat by McCallie over the weekend and BA blasted McCallie by 35. Seems to me its a no brainer here...Middle Tn has the best team in the state hands down.

    Well, except Hamilton Heights beat Brentwood Academy, so that is sort of a circular hypothesis.

    Could BA be the best team? Yes.
    But are they the best hands down, I don't think so.
    I think it is clear that the top 3 teams in the state are BA, Memphis East & Hamilton Heights.
    Hamilton Heights beat both of the other two, so they have the strongest argument.
    I think McCallie just played out of their minds vs HH to win & they conversely sucked an egg this week vs BA. The reality is that McCallie probably is 4th out of this group, but they knocked off the best team... I guess that is why they play the games...
    All that being said, I'd pay good money to see East vs BA...

    Edited by FootballFan51, 2 weeks ago.

    • 0

    #3 UCSportsFan

    UCSportsFan

      Most Valuable Player

    • CoachT+
    • 5,643 posts

    Posted 2 weeks ago

    Well, except Hamilton Heights beat Brentwood Academy, so that is sort of a circular hypothesis.

    Could BA be the best team? Yes.
    But are they the best hands down, I don't think so.
    I think it is clear that the top 3 teams in the state are BA, Memphis East & Hamilton Heights.
    Hamilton Heights beat both of the other two, so they have the strongest argument.
    I think McCallie just played out of their minds vs HH to win & they conversely sucked an egg this week vs BA. The reality is that McCallie probably is 4th out of this group, but they knocked off the best team... I guess that is why they play the games...
    All that being said, I'd pay good money to see East vs BA...

    Yeah so would I!  It would be a great game to watch for sure.   HH is definitely in the conversation, what a 4 team tourney that would be! 


    • 0
    Everyone looks good in "WARM-UPS"

    #4 865BB

    865BB

      Advanced Member

    • Members
    • PipPipPip
    • 78 posts

    Posted 2 weeks ago

    BA probably has the best coach in the state so that's a big plus for them.


    • 0

    #5 MoonDogRex

    MoonDogRex

      Trainer

    • Members
    • 108 posts

    Posted 2 weeks ago

    HH doesn't play by the same rules as BA or ME, so it's not a valid comparison. Look at what the national ranking services have done the last few years regarding teams like Oak Hill, Findlay Prep, Montverde, Huntington Prep, and La Lumiere. HH is in that category, overtly recruiting basketball players to the high school in a process that would not be legal in the TSSAA.

     

    Also, HH losing to McCallie has a lot to do with the fact that they have already played 30 games this season and are probably worn out. 


    • 0

    #6 TonyG

    TonyG

      Competitor

    • Members
    • 395 posts

    Posted 2 weeks ago

    I dont get into who beat who to cancel out who's the better opponent. BA could beat East they've done it two summers in a row(yes summer ball i know) in Memphis. Hubie is a great coach but that team goes as far as Garland leads them and there isn't a pg in the STATE that can stop him. The two times i saw them play eachother, J.O. had big games both times and Garland had around 30 pts and set up teammates for open threes. BA played ball hawking D and didn't let TJ moss get going and Lomax(didn't play in the 2016 matchup) wasn't able to bully Garland like he does some. The top teams of DII-AA are extremely undervalued in my eyes. I also saw East barely beat a CBHS team that was basically 1 on 5 over the summer but thats another story. East also had two kids in the summer that are back at Hamilton now that are studs on the Highschool level that would've made a tremendous difference coming off the bench, and it could be argued if they had these two guys for depth they would be undefeated and champions of both of the big tournaments they lost. 


    Edited by TonyG, 2 weeks ago.

    • 0

    #7 MoonDogRex

    MoonDogRex

      Trainer

    • Members
    • 108 posts

    Posted 2 weeks ago

    Also, ME is 2-1 against Montverde this season, whose only other loss was to Imhotep Charter of PA, currently ranked 8th in the nation. ME is ranked 4th.


    • 0

    #8 MoonDogRex

    MoonDogRex

      Trainer

    • Members
    • 108 posts

    Posted 2 weeks ago

    Finally, BA's schedule isn't even as remotely difficult as ME's is. ME is the best team in TN, and a Dec. 1 loss to HH doesn't change that. HH begins practicing from the first day of school, so by December 1, they are firing on all cylinders -- hence worn out now. 

     

    Let's see where the final national rankings fall, and then we can talk.


    • 0

    #9 TonyG

    TonyG

      Competitor

    • Members
    • 395 posts

    Posted 2 weeks ago

    HH doesn't play by the same rules as BA or ME, so it's not a valid comparison. Look at what the national ranking services have done the last few years regarding teams like Oak Hill, Findlay Prep, Montverde, Huntington Prep, and La Lumiere. HH is in that category, overtly recruiting basketball players to the high school in a process that would not be legal in the TSSAA.

     

    Also, HH losing to McCallie has a lot to do with the fact that they have already played 30 games this season and are probably worn out. 

    McCallie has played 30 games also. We all know how basketball is. Anyone can be beat on any night when the talent level isn't a huge gap. I wouldn't pick Memphis East to lose against HH again, and I wouldnt pick HH to lose to McCallie if they played tomorrow. 


    Edited by TonyG, 2 weeks ago.

    • 1

    #10 UCSportsFan

    UCSportsFan

      Most Valuable Player

    • CoachT+
    • 5,643 posts

    Posted 2 weeks ago

    I dont get into who beat who to cancel out who's the better opponent. BA could beat East they've done it two summers in a row(yes summer ball i know) in Memphis. Hubie is a great coach but that team goes as far as Garland leads them and there isn't a pg in the STATE that can stop him. The two times i saw them play J.O. had big games both times and Garland had around 30 pts and set up teammates for open threes. BA played ball hawking D and didn't let TJ moss get going and Lomax(didn't play in the 2016 matchup) wasn't able to bully Garland like he does some. The top teams of DII-AA are extremely undervalued in my eyes. I also saw East barely beat a CBHS team that was basically 1 on 5 over the summer but thats another story. East also had two kids in the summer that are back at Hamilton now that are studs on the Highschool level that would've made a tremendous difference coming off the bench, and it could be argued if they had these two guys for depth they would be undefeated and champions of both of the big tournaments they lost. 

    Great evaluation!


    • 0
    Everyone looks good in "WARM-UPS"




    Spirit Style Chooser: