Sounds like a bunch of complaining to me. Sorry that your team can't beat Alcoa but that does not mean they are doing anything wrong.
Every great public program has a few things in common: Development, Coaching, Administrative and Fan support and Culture. Alcoa checks off all those boxes, no suprise a few players transfer in to be a part of that. The core of their success is due to the kids that have been with them since Youth Football. It's not rocket science but requires 100% buy in from everyone