4A-6A TWSA All State teams

[HTV]

Our today:

 

2021 TSWA All-State Football Teams: Class 4A, 5A, 6A - Five Star Preps (5starpreps.com)

[cbg]

Just a question, but why have All-State teams selected by division?  The athletes are either good enough to be on one combined All-State team or they are not.  Congratulations to some really good athletes but to have multiple All-State teams is just another way to “WATER DOWN” football in Tennessee and try to make everyone feel good.

[HTV]

3 minutes ago, cbg said:

Just a question, but why have All-State teams selected by division?  The athletes are either good enough to be on one combined All-State team or they are not.  Congratulations to some really good athletes but to have multiple All-State teams is just another way to “WATER DOWN” football in Tennessee and try to make everyone feel good.

Well, we do live in an "everybody gets a trophy" society.  

I believe there are still one or two all state teams that select irregardless of classification.  

[cbg]

Just now, HTV said:

Well, we do live in an "everybody gets a trophy" society.  

I believe there are still one or two all state teams that select irregardless of classification.  

Just like you said “EVERYONE GET’S A TROPHY SOCIETY

[Swipes]

3 minutes ago, cbg said:

Just a question, but why have All-State teams selected by division?  The athletes are either good enough to be on one combined All-State team or they are not.  Congratulations to some really good athletes but to have multiple All-State teams is just another way to “WATER DOWN” football in Tennessee and try to make everyone feel good.

Do you really think other states do it anyway different?  If giving out All-State teams per division is "Watering it Down" then i guess GA,FL, Al,TX, etc have "water down" teams then too.  Heck Florida even has 1st, 2nd, and 3rd teams per Classification.

[cbg]

41 minutes ago, Swipes said:

Do you really think other states do it anyway different?  If giving out All-State teams per division is "Watering it Down" then i guess GA,FL, Al,TX, etc have "water down" teams then too.  Heck Florida even has 1st, 2nd, and 3rd teams per Classification.

EVERYONE GETS A TROPHY

[MidTennFootball]

15 minutes ago, cbg said:

EVERYONE GETS A TROPHY

TSWA does an all state for every class and has done so for a long time. Get sore at the TSSAA if you want, not the kids that have worked hard to be recognized

[Swipes]

21 minutes ago, cbg said:

EVERYONE GETS A TROPHY

Here is the problem with your first comment, you made it sound like it’s ONLY Tennessee that does it that way and not every other state also. (Even powerhouse football states).

 

Here is a question for you, do you believe that there should be 1 All-American team in College Football?  

[ILB1999]

1 minute ago, Swipes said:

Here is the problem with your first comment, you made it sound like it’s ONLY Tennessee that does it that way and not every other state also. (Even powerhouse football states).

 

Here is a question for you, do you believe that there should be 1 All-American team in College Football?  

and only one post-season bowl?

Edited January 18, 2022 by ILB1999WHS

[cbg]

54 minutes ago, Swipes said:

Here is the problem with your first comment, you made it sound like it’s ONLY Tennessee that does it that way and not every other state also. (Even powerhouse football states).

 

Here is a question for you, do you believe that there should be 1 All-American team in College Football?  

Yes

[cbg]

55 minutes ago, ILB1999WHS said:

and only one post-season bowl?

There can only be “ONE CHAMPION” each year.  Everyone wants a trophy!

[Swipes]

55 minutes ago, cbg said:

Yes

I guess we should get rid of all the D3, D2, NAIA, and Championship Subdivision too and every Bowl game thats not the Final 4 .  Heck lets get rid of everything thats not the NFL since those would be the best teams and then you can have your One True Champion each year with the Super Bowl