West Carroll @ Lake County (Quarterfinals)

[Mustang1969]

1 minute ago, Outsider1998 said:

I can’t tell if you’re trolling or being serious these days 

I thought Snyder was the kid I saw in jr high a couple years ago.

[ItsAlwaysSunnyInAtwood]

31 minutes ago, Outsider1998 said:

Any player nominated is going to be a great player, I agree. But it just makes you wonder what criteria do you go off? Id like to hear the people that actually vote give their reasoning for picking who they picked 

Most of these voters wouldn't even recognize a Mr. Football candidate they just voted for if the kid was standing in front of him and wearing his home  jersey 

[RedStateReject]

25 minutes ago, Mustang1969 said:

I thought Snyder was the kid I saw in jr high a couple years ago.

When Huntingdon played Lake Co in the middle school jamboree 2 years ago, Cayden Puckett was the QB then.

[Mustang1969]

15 minutes ago, RedStateReject said:

When Huntingdon played Lake Co in the middle school jamboree 2 years ago, Cayden Puckett was the QB then.

Gotcha. Thanks.

[Mustang1969]

Hey guys! Puckett is being mentioned as a candidate for the opening at Milan over on the 3A-4A thread. Any comments?

[shockernation]

5 minutes ago, Mustang1969 said:

Hey guys! Puckett is being mentioned as a candidate for the opening at Milan over on the 3A-4A thread. Any comments?

Old news...we can talk about this in a couple weeks 

[horse]

6 hours ago, cherokee23 said:

As stated in my previous post, I said I believed Snyder should have been on the list over Tipton. As far as the award goes, it’s not all about stats. If we’re basing it ALL off stats, GB WR is going to break the record for receiving TD’s in a single season in Tennessee history. But it’s about passing the eye test and who the overall better player is. You can see it’s not all based on stats because Tipton didn’t have the stats to even be considered for the award in my opinion but he’s a really good player that can change a game in an instant. 

It’s funny how a school the size of south Pitt has a player nominated near every year. When they did the lineman and back award they have one or two nearly every year. 

[cherokee23]

9 minutes ago, horse said:

It’s funny how a school the size of south Pitt has a player nominated near every year. When they did the lineman and back award they have one or two nearly every year. 

Well they're usually pretty good and have been successful so I can see why. But I still see what you're saying. If we go off of who means more to their team and stats, the edge goes to Snyder. The athletic ability is on Tipton's side. Still not enough in my opinion for him to be a finalist over Snyder.

[Pirate2003]

18 minutes ago, horse said:

It’s funny how a school the size of south Pitt has a player nominated near every year. When they did the lineman and back award they have one or two nearly every year. 

This is the first SP kid to be named a finalist since 2013. Last time I checked that was 6 years between nominations. 

[Guidance1812]

5 hours ago, cherokee23 said:

Well they're usually pretty good and have been successful so I can see why. But I still see what you're saying. If we go off of who means more to their team and stats, the edge goes to Snyder. The athletic ability is on Tipton's side. Still not enough in my opinion for him to be a finalist over Snyder.

That’s 3!

[mrbigster]

13 hours ago, Mustang1969 said:

Hey guys! Puckett is being mentioned as a candidate for the opening at Milan over on the 3A-4A thread. Any comments?

Hall of Fame coach Bobby Sharp should be talked to .Wife is from Milan.But I'd think it will be one of Milan's former players that's coaching now.

[TipToe421]

I know things are quite in here recently.  If you think the talk about LC and Huntingdon was getting a little crazy jump over the Dyer County/Henry County thread in 5A.  They are going at it over there......