Jump to content
Reporting Scores to CoachT ×
How to edit games

State Semifinal: Maryville at Oakland

BigDave1967

By BigDave1967
in Class 5A & Class 6A

 Share

Recommended Posts

BlackHavenSenator Record Holder

BlackHavenSenator

Posted
Posted

This is not true. The expanded neutral zone is about 3 yards on every single snap that doesn't have center protection. I can give you the page and rule number for LOS and the "try" in the 2012 rulebook if you'd like. He made the call. It was wrong. It can't be changed now. Hope for a rubber match.  

 

Provide said page or link

Link to comment
Share on other sites
  • Replies 957
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Popular Days

Top Posters In This Topic

Popular Days

Popular Posts

StorkMontgomery
StorkMontgomery

Highlights from bottom view are up.

StorkMontgomery
StorkMontgomery

Look if Blackhaven makes it in great until then lets play the game....

PassiveAggressive
PassiveAggressive

BIG DAVE IS TROLLIN EVERYWHERE...YAL AINT MAD AT HIM....OH HE JOCK RIDES...

qb#7 Contender

qb#7

Posted
Posted

Provide said page or link

For the try it is on page 64, 8.3.2 situation C (there is no reference to there being any difference in the expanded neutral zone therefore there is no change)

 

Expanded neutral zone is defined on page 61, 7.5.12 situation A (this is the reference that matters pertaining to expanded neutral zone on a forward pass; the term "about" is a judgment definition and referees are told not to use their judgment to effect the game unless the foul is extreme)

 

http://www.mbfo.org/files/2012NFHS_FootballCaseBook.pdf

Link to comment
Share on other sites
qb#7 Contender

qb#7

Posted
Posted

I remember hearing it while watching college football. It makes sense when you really think about it...  

College rule is different from High School in this regard. The HS rule requires contact and the college rule requires none. Also the depth is determined when the ball crosses the neutral zone. So it basically where the lineman is when the ball leaves the QB's hand, not where he is when he catches it. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites
warhawks Record Holder

warhawks

Posted
Posted

it was hard using all my fingers and toes!!! i agree with the opponents still playing especially when people comment on how weak of a schedule murvil plays and how tough oakland's district is.  before anybody jumps my arse about it......... I"M NOT saying O's distrit is weak-just sayin

u r correct tho-all of it aint gonna matter friday night 

Thats why I say that is all hogwash! 7AAA is not any better or tougher then Maryvilles region! Time for 7AAA to put up or shut up! Just my two cents which are not worth 2 cents!

Link to comment
Share on other sites
OldRebel2 Contender

OldRebel2

Posted
Posted (edited)

College rule is different from High School in this regard. The HS rule requires contact and the college rule requires none. Also the depth is determined when the ball crosses the neutral zone. So it basically where the lineman is when the ball leaves the QB's hand, not where he is when he catches it. 

Too complicated for BHS.  He's already proved many times that he can understand.  We're in a recession, many comedians out of work, and BHS keeps cracking jokes!  That's not really fair that he keeps taking the comedians jobs!

 

I agree with BHS on one point.  The play would not have given the Rebels the victory.  However, there should have never been an overtime!

Edited by OldRebel2
Link to comment
Share on other sites
qb#7 Contender

qb#7

Posted
Posted

LOL....Thainks for tha collidge rools...... B)

It isn't even a rule in college. A play from scrimmage has the same rules anywhere on the field. The only thing that changes is when the snap is taken at 7 yards or more. This gives the center protection from being hit with his head down. Other than that everything is the same.

 

I've had this conversation a few times Stars! Both levels. It is part of my smoke and mirror package!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
 Share
Go to topic listing

Announcements

  • Recent Posts

    • Chiefbigfoot
      Way too early 1A favorites 2024

      By Chiefbigfoot · Posted

      I don't believe they have anyone that is surbers caliber but a decent staff overall.
    • 1983
      Way too early 1A favorites 2024

      By 1983 · Posted

      Richland plays at McKenzie on Wed.  Should be a good series.  Does Richland have good pitching?  
    • CoyDillard
      Marion Co. 2024

      By CoyDillard · Posted

      Congratulations to the Warrior baseball team winning the Region Championship.  Last night the football team beat Franklin Co 33-0 in their spring scrimmage. Warriors looked very good. Missing a few players who were playing baseball but still absolutely dominated. A lot of young ones got in halfway through the 3rd when the score reached 33-0. QB Tilton Pickett looked very sharp.  Sam Pickett is on another level this season. Seems to have put on 15 to 20 lbs in the off season and added a step as well. Transfer from last year Williamson caught numerous balls and is very elusive. Lots of athletes on this team. Defense was smothering and will only get better. The head coach from Sewanee was in attendance and offered 2 kids after the game. Could be a special year.
    • Chiefbigfoot
      Way too early 1A favorites 2024

      By Chiefbigfoot · Posted

      ER will travel to South Pitt.
    • runtheball
      Metro Rankings

      By runtheball · Posted

      I heard Alabama was at Antioch practice and Colorado has offered QB. Hoping the Bears have a great year.  
×
×
  • Create New...