Jump to content

This is why we need instant replay...


Recommended Posts

When it's that close you don't penalize the team that is ahead at the time, it should go against the team that's behind unless it's obviously good. Bad call.

I agree, it appears from looking at the film that the shot was late. It's unfortunate and a downright shame when any team loses on a bad call, but I still believe calls should be made "the way they see them," regardless of who's leading or behind.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I'm not a basketball official but until your out there refing the game in real time officials will miss calls there human. But that was so close I can see why they called it good. Yes thanks to video you can slow the play down and tell it's no good. McMinn Central dug to big of a hole in the first half and it came back to bit them

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guys (and let me say I was for Cannon County) but seriously!!! Enough over the nanna-second that the shot may or may not have been out of her hand. Real time, couldn't tell at all. Slowed down to the nth degree, perhaps a stitch of leather is still touching a fingertip (I don't know). Bottom line is ref(s) called the shot good so it's good. Why not quit whining about the nth of a second it may or may not have counted. Why not talk about the FOURTEEN (14) free throws McMinn MISSED. That doesn't even include the ones they made. If not the the three blind mice officiating this game McMinnn would have never been in it. There were more missed calls and no calls on McMinn fouls as I have ever seen in a 32 minute game. McMinn pressed and trapped the entire time (especially second half down 13 when they had to turn the pressure up) and Cannon County NEVER (i repeat) NEVER shot a 1-and-1 the entire game. Cannon County players just didn't all of a sudden forget how to dribble and protect the ball. They were being hacked and pushed when losing the ball and McMinn coming back. The officials did enough to help McMinn's cause. You will have to overlook them for the final tenth of a second they opted to finally let something go. They had the entire game.

Bottom line, there is plenty of complaining and whining to do. The shot (clock) is just one small part but happened to be at the end.

The biggest problem I see in that gym with a large crowd is the McMinn students being allowed on the baseline while action is going on. There is barely room to navigate or move (for the players or officials). I saw a Cannon County player more than 2 feet out of bounds on the baseline where McMinn students were twice in the first half and it wasn't called b/c the refs were not in position to see it.

Great game. Ladies on both teams played hard. Get over it and move on. Had the shot been waved off I doubt we would have had the slowed down video from McMinn. For the record, the angle from where the Cannon County video sits shows the shot did get off just in a knick of time.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

When they go to instant replay, I believe the sound of the horn is used before the time on the clock. Plus, the horn is what the refs have to go by and she may have gotten it off before the horn sounded. Just cause the clock hit 0.00 doesn't mean the horn went off exactly at that point.

 

Exactly the horn is a little delayed. Bottom line here is 10/24 from the foul line ended up being the difference and foul shots are always big in a close game. I hate it for the young lady's from MC they played their hearts out. Congrats to CC girls and good luck next week!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

TNPreps let's see the video, I don't know how anyone can argue the shot should have counted when looking at the slow motion replay. I have no dog in the hunt but is obvious the refs missed one. Now nothing can be done but to just flat out deny that the call was incorrect shows you have some type of bias.

 

From every video and photo I have seen she did not give it off in time, if you think otherwise show proof.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Lol CC was up consistently throughout the game and by as many as 13. Everyone is acting like the MUCH better team was cheated and won't continue and what not. Looks like a team of equal quality is advancing and what's done is done. MC missed 14 free throws. That should haunt them just as bad, but it's easier to blame the last shot than it is to look back at something you actually COULD'VE changed. I still want to see a video of the clock from the throw in. The play itself took a little over four seconds. Everyone says there was 6.2 seconds on the clock.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

When they go to instant replay, I believe the sound of the horn is used before the time on the clock. Plus, the horn is what the refs have to go by and she may have gotten it off before the horn sounded. Just cause the clock hit 0.00 doesn't mean the horn went off exactly at that point.

 

The referees use the horn. The clock can read 0.0 before the horn sounds. In the video, I believe I hear the horn berfore the shot has left the player's hand. It is very difficult to tell.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

 

 

The referees use the horn. The clock can read 0.0 before the horn sounds. In the video, I believe I hear the horn berfore the shot has left the player's hand. It is very difficult to tell.

 

I was trying to listen for that too, but I was also on my phone without headphones. All I heard was the roar of the crowd!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Announcements


  • Recent Posts

    • The 106, 113,126,132,175 were guys that started for us Tuesday. SO no we did not lose 14 starters between Tuesday and Thursday.  There are two more chances to seee those match ups. 
    • PC was really really good before the past few years. In 2018 (just 7 years ago), PC had their best chance to win the State Championship before losing a 13 pt lead in the 3rd qtr to the eventual State Champs (Greenfield) that had, I believe, 3 D1 prospects (two played for Tn Vols).
    • This is correct. I made the exact same observation about 10 or so years ago. I used to watched PC get beat by the Clarkrange's of the world by 30-40 points. Then year after year, there were noticeable changes to the PC program. They started AAU and playing together all the time. Whether that is solely on current SC coach or the fact the players played together ALL the time, I'm not sure. But PC basketball got TONS better once that system was in place.
    • So Sammy, you lost 14 wrestlers from Tuesday to Thursday? Now I do understand the flu has sucked this year, most of Soddy had it earlier in the season and had to cancel going to a tourney. Plus it helps keep the other team healthy not having to wrestle sick guys.  Just hate sickness and injuries knocked out pretty much 14 guys that wrestled against Stone Memorial and Sam Everett!  I was hopeful to see Sudderth vs Wade and Davis vs Harris. Guess we will hopefully see those matchups in a few weeks with sectionals!
    • This game will finally be played Monday after a couple of cancellations.  Kingston is the reigning District champ and last year it was “Tellico is young, but has great potential.” and now the Bears are here, ranked t5 in the state by TSWA.  Tyner will be a tough out in region, but the winner of Kingston/Tyner/Tellico will do good to avoid Alcoa in the sectional. 
×
  • Create New...