Time to move Alcoa to 6A

[MrTwister]

 

[Throwdeslant]

13 minutes ago, MrTwister said:

 

[Jmm475]

39 minutes ago, FIREBIRD80 said:

Two schools? But PC has played up matter fact we have better success in 4A than 3A. Look if you have problem with MLK 6 players on our team, contact tssaa with your problem!!!

It may be 6 but what’s stopping it from being 30? Both enrollments should count. If it wasn’t the team you pulled for you’d agree! I understand why they get to play with PC but can’t understand why their enrollment doesn’t count. 

[tradertwo]

3 minutes ago, Jmm475 said:

It may be 6 but what’s stopping it from being 30? Both enrollments should count. If it wasn’t the team you pulled for you’d agree! I understand why they get to play with PC but can’t understand why their enrollment doesn’t count. 

Don't have a problem with the school, if you're mad, be mad at the rule! Many schools co-op kids who haven't the opportunity to play otherwise, and that's a good thing. PC wins with (probably without) those kids, so you have a problem with them, but not the other schools? Same as the Alcoa argument...don't single out someone who is successful, from the same system and rules as everyone else just because they do it better. Don't gripe because PC is good, if you don't think the co-op rules are fair, gripe about the rules and leave PC out of it.

[FIREBIRD80]

50 minutes ago, tradertwo said:

Don't have a problem with the school, if you're mad, be mad at the rule! Many schools co-op kids who haven't the opportunity to play otherwise, and that's a good thing. PC wins with (probably without) those kids, so you have a problem with them, but not the other schools? Same as the Alcoa argument...don't single out someone who is successful, from the same system and rules as everyone else just because they do it better. Don't gripe because PC is good, if you don't think the co-op rules are fair, gripe about the rules and leave PC out of it.

Exactly!!

[FIREBIRD80]

1 hour ago, Jmm475 said:

It may be 6 but what’s stopping it from being 30? Both enrollments should count. If it wasn’t the team you pulled for you’d agree! I understand why they get to play with PC but can’t understand why their enrollment doesn’t count. 

Take it up with Tssaa!!!

[BatmanDevil]

Alcoa is right where they are supposed to be.People are just going to have to live with the fact that Alcoa and Maryville are the two best in their own class most every year and can beat most teams nomatter what class they are in. Be glad they don't build a school right between the two and consolidate.

[BIGPURPLEMACHINE]

6 hours ago, coachrus said:

If you are an open zone school and win a championship you move up a division. Just like almost every other state. 

80+% of the teams in TN are open zone. Why does that matter??

[BIGPURPLEMACHINE]

4 hours ago, tradertwo said:

What would it mean to you if TSSAA "moved" Alcoa up, and your team won a championship in their rightful classification? To me that would be a hollow victory, and your notion of "fair play" equates to the "everyone gets a participation trophy" mentality that has turned a generation of young people into entitled brats. Gordonsville won a championship in 1A a few years back with 22 seniors on the team, and returned only one or two starters (had a hard time competing with lower echelon teams the following year)...should they have been moved up too, and if not, what is the difference? I'm just not on board with bringing down the best to everyone else's level instead of endeavoring to elevate myself to their level in order to compete.

Exactly!!!

[Domin18]

7 hours ago, BCsportsfan said:

Thanks sweetheart!

4a is no competition for Alcoa. If Alcoa choose to move to 5A they would fix 4a again everyone that moved up will move back down. Then Maryville and Alcoa can win the state championship in 5A and 6A every year....lol

Edited September 8, 2018 by Domin18

[BCsportsfan]

39 minutes ago, Domin18 said:

4a is no competition for Alcoa. If Alcoa choose to move to 5A they would fix 4a again everyone that moved up will move back down. Then Maryville and Alcoa can win the state championship in 5A and 6A every year....lol

Very true!

[BatmanDevil]

Could just do like 1938 and take the 10 best teams in the state for a playoff.